Fr. Ron Rolheiser, in a thoughtful reflection on “Generous Orthodoxy”, hints at a nuanced answer. He first confronts us with an unpleasant truth: in our faith (and in our politics), we are polarized and we are polarizing. We often see those with other worldviews as evil, foolish, or blind. Even our prayers risk becoming judgmental and presumptuous: “Dear God, help our leaders see and do things my way.” We are in danger of becoming the Pharisee in Luke 18, thanking God that we are “not like the rest of humanity.”

To help us soften this unfortunate tendency, Fr. Rolheiser proposes a worldview that many call generous orthodoxy: the word generous invites us to respect and appreciate the experiences of others, while orthodoxy captures the need to remain firmly grounded in our own spiritual roots.

Praying – and living – in the spirit of generous orthodoxy demands a healthy dose of spiritual and intellectual humility. It requires quieting ourselves so we can hear God’s whisper in the voice of a neighbor. It means letting go of the need to control the agenda and win every argument. It involves discernment: trusting God to help us understand and embrace our own role in fostering compassionate leadership.

Prayerful discernment will lead us in directions as varied as our gifts and passions. But we can all put in the effort needed to choose leaders of character, model in our own lives the compassionate leadership we seek in our leaders, and see more of ourselves in each other. Would this change the world? It might at least change the neighborhood: maybe we’d find ourselves better equipped to serve our migrant neighbors, for example, without dehumanizing those we ask to uphold our laws.

The U.S. Catholic bishops have much to say about these matters in “Forming Consciences for Faithful Citizenship”, a thoughtful, wise document that anchors an initiative the bishops call “Civilize It”. The bishops show us that faithful citizenship is both important and holy, and they appeal to all people of good will to engage in ways that align with the essence of who they are – a call to fidelity, integrity, and orthodoxy.

But the bishops also remind us that faithful citizenship is messy. They tell us repeatedly that no political party comes even close to representing what our faith requires of us. They help us understand that even when we agree on foundational moral principles, our policy judgments and voting choices will vary. This reality demands what Pope Francis called “a better kind of politics” — a call for respect, civility, and generosity.

The important, holy, and messy work of faithful citizenship demands generous orthodoxy – fidelity to our core values combined with respect for our differences. That means looking within ourselves, learning to listen with respect and humility, and – as people like to say – praying with our feet. Let us pray!

Commenting on the statement, Cardinal Cupich stated, “As pastors entrusted with the teaching of our people, we cannot stand by while decisions are made that condemn millions to lives trapped permanently at the edge of existence. Pope Leo has given us clear direction and we must apply his teachings to the conduct of our nation and its leaders.”

Cardinal McElroy offered these thoughts: “Catholic social teaching testifies that when national interest narrowly conceived excludes the moral imperative of solidarity among nations and the dignity of the human person, it brings immense suffering to the world and a catastrophic assault on the just peace that benefits every nation and is the will of God.” Further he noted, “In our current national debate about the fundamental contours of American foreign policy, we ignore this reality at the cost of our country’s truest interests and the best traditions of this land that we love.”

Cardinal Tobin remarked that, “Recent events, including participation in last week’s consistory in Rome with Pope Leo and brother cardinals from across the world, convince me of the need to underscore the vision of Pope Leo for just and peaceful relations among nations. Otherwise, escalating threats and armed conflict risk destroying international relations and plunging the world into incalculable suffering.”

The full text of their statement follows below.

Charting A Moral Vision of American Foreign Policy

In 2026, the United States has entered into the most profound and searing debate about the moral foundation for America’s actions in the world since the end of the Cold War. The events in Venezuela, Ukraine and Greenland have raised basic questions about the use of military force and the meaning of peace. The sovereign rights of nations to self-determination appear all too fragile in a world of ever greater conflagrations. The balancing of national interest with the common good is being framed within starkly polarized terms. Our country’s moral role in confronting evil around the world, sustaining the right to life and human dignity, and supporting religious liberty are all under examination. And the building of just and sustainable peace, so crucial to humanity’s well-being now and in the future, is being reduced to partisan categories that encourage polarization and destructive policies.

For all of these reasons, the contribution of Pope Leo in outlining a truly moral foundation for international relations to the Vatican diplomatic corps this month has provided us an enduring ethical compass for establishing the pathway for American foreign policy in the coming years. He stated:

In our time, the weakness of multilateralism is a particular cause for concern at the international level. A diplomacy that promotes dialogue and seeks consensus among all parties is being replaced by a diplomacy based on force, by either individuals or groups of allies. War is back in vogue and a zeal for war is spreading. The principle established after the Second World War, which prohibited nations from using force to violate the borders of others, has been completely undermined. Peace is no longer sought as a gift and desirable good in itself, or in pursuit of “the establishment of the ordered universe willed by God with a more perfect form of justice among men and women.” Instead, peace is sought through weapons as a condition for asserting one’s own dominion.

Pope Leo also reiterates Catholic teaching that “the protection of the right to life constitutes the indispensable foundation for every other human right” and that abortion and euthanasia are destructive of that right. He points to the need for international aid to safeguard the most central elements of human dignity, which are under assault because of the movement by wealthy nations to reduce or eliminate their contributions to humanitarian foreign assistance programs. Finally, the Holy Father points to the increasing violations of conscience and religious freedom in the name of an ideological or religious purity that crushes freedom itself.

As pastors and citizens, we embrace this vision for the establishment of a genuinely moral foreign policy for our nation. We seek to build a truly just and lasting peace, that peace which Jesus proclaimed in the Gospel. We renounce war as an instrument for narrow national interests and proclaim that military action must be seen only as a last resort in extreme situations, not a normal instrument of national policy. We seek a foreign policy that respects and advances the right to human life, religious liberty, and the enhancement of human dignity throughout the world, especially through economic assistance.

Our nation’s debate on the moral foundation for American policy is beset by polarization, partisanship, and narrow economic and social interests. Pope Leo has given us the prism through which to raise it to a much higher level. We will preach, teach, and advocate in the coming months to make that higher level possible.

Signed,
Cardinal Blase J. Cupich, Archbishop of Chicago
Cardinal Robert W. McElroy, Archbishop of Washington
Cardinal Joseph W. Tobin, C.Ss.R., Archbishop of Newark

Source: Archdiocese of Washington website